8 Home Items That Are Always Better to Buy Thrifted (Rather Than New)

If you’re in the market for a purchase for your home, whether it’s furniture or accessories, you might wonder whether it’s better to buy new or secondhand. Or you might worry that what you buy in a thrift store might not be as good as something brand new. According to our thrifting experts, that’s just not the case.

In fact, some household furnishings are actually better (and more valuable!) if you purchase them secondhand. So which ones should you snag without a second doubt on your next hunt? Our experts are spilling the secrets.

1. Wood Furniture

Furniture can be a smart secondhand purchase, especially pieces from the mid-20th century, says interior designer Gideon Mendelson. Vintage furniture was often made from solid hardwoods like oak, walnut, and mahogany, making these pieces much more durable than some of today’s furnishings, he says. Plus, vintage furniture often features dovetail joinery and hand-carved details that used to be standard but today would cost extra.

2. Decorative Ceramics

Don’t hesitate to buy vintage ceramics if you spot them, as these pieces are “more durable and beautifully designed compared to the mass-produced pieces of today,” Mendelson says. Plus, vintage ceramics often unique, handmade details you won’t find in newer iterations. And ceramics don’t tend to depreciate in value over time so they are a stylish, investment-worthy piece to thrift.

Examine your piece for any cracks or chips as these can affect the value and functionality of your ceramic.

3. Rugs

When thrifting, also keep area rugs on your radar. They often feature “better quality fibers and highly-skilled artisans who fabricated them,” Mendelson says. Vintage rugs often feature intricate patterns, designs, colors, unique patinas, and durable materials like wool or silk.

Vintage rugs may harbor years of dirt so inspect your finds for any major fading or stains that can’t be cleaned or repaired. And check your rug’s backing to see if it’s structurally intact.

4. Upholstered Furniture

Interior designer Jonathan Savage suggests you look for upholstered furniture that has a solid wood frame, which he says are “hard to beat.” Solid-wood frames, especially older ones, were meticulously crafted using traditional techniques, ensuring their structural integrity. Plus, with an intact wood frame, you can always breathe new life into your piece by reupholstering it in a fabric that reflects your style, Savage says.

Reupholstering can be an added expense, so if you can, try getting a quote from your local upholsterer so you’ll know the costs up front before deciding to buy.

5. Decorative Lamps

“A pair of beautiful vintage lamps is always a great way to add character and eclecticism to a home,” says Savage. Older lamps often have distinctive designs you won’t see in today’s market, whether you’re going for a midcentury modern, art deco, or more traditional style. Older lamps were also constructed with materials like copper, glass, and brass rather than plastic or other low-quality materials. That means vintage lamps can be great for future resale as some collectors actively seek them.

6. Mirrors

For another timeless and practical addition to your home, you can’t go wrong with vintage mirrors, Mendelson says. Older mirrors also were constructed of “higher-quality glass, wood, and metal frames,” making them a durable purchase. Savage prefers vintage mirrors over new because he says the ornate or gilded designs can add add easy elegance to any space.

Plus, mirrors can hold their value over time, especially if you scout a piece from a certain time period or designer. Be sure to inspect your mirror for any damage, moisture, or mold, and always examine it’s frame for durability.

7. Kitchenware

“Kitchenware can often be a valuable buy in the secondhand market,” Mendelson says. In some cases, it can actually last you longer than new pieces. Vintage glassware, cast iron skillets, wooden utensils, vintage Pyrex, or ceramic dishware can all be prime finds. Always check for rust, cracks, or chips. Avoid uranium glassware, which can emit low radiation.

8. Art and Wall Decor

You can find handpainted art at a fraction of the cost of new. Artwork goes beyond paintings and can mean different things to different people. Maybe for you, it’s building a small wall display of vintage clocks, hanging a stacked pair of lush landscape oil paintings, or displaying a black-and-white antique etching of your favorite city. Whatever you choose, it’s important to be intentional in your selection. Choose pieces that feel meaningful to you and have a rough idea of where you’ll hang them before you buy.