The Best Hotels in the Hamptons – Elite Traveler

Thanks to its proximity to New York City, during the latter half of the 19^th century and early 20^th century, the Hamptons became synonymous with luxury. Wealthy New York City highfliers began buying land and estates on Long Island, where they would spend the weekend in relative peace, and so this corner of New York swiftly became prime real estate.

Today, the picture remains much the same. A boom in the 1980s caused a second rush, and thanks to the wonder of private aviation, the Hamptons is no longer reserved for wealthy New Yorkers, it seems anybody who’s anybody now owns a Hamptons holiday home.

If there’s one thing a sustained period of popularity among the elites will give an area, it is an impressive amount of choice when it comes to luxury hotels, and the Hamptons is certainly not bucking the trend.

Here are the best hotels in the Hamptons.

• 
  

  Gurney’s Montauk Seawater Spa & Resort

  A Montauk icon, Gurney’s Montauk Seawater Spa & Resort sits directly on a private stretch of oceanfront, offering guests the best of Hamptons living. With newly reimagined rooms and suites, the property is a blend of classic seaside charm and modern refinement. The resort’s famed Seawater Spa, complete with ocean-fed pools and thalassotherapy treatments, is a destination in itself, while the beach club, renowned restaurants, and lively social scene make it a favorite among discerning East End travelers. From sunrise yoga to fireside cocktails, every detail is designed to celebrate the restorative rhythm of the coast.

• 
  

  The Roundtree, Amagansett

  With just a handful of rooms, suites, and private cottages, The Roundtree, Amagansett, reimagines the East End guesthouse experience. This meticulously restored 120-year-old property blends pastoral charm with modern ease—think landscaped lawns, complimentary picnics, and an open invitation to borrow a beach cruiser or s’mores kit at sunset. The service is highly personalized, from curated local recommendations to in-room breakfast delivered daily. Perfectly situated on Main Street, The Roundtree is minutes from Amagansett’s top shops, restaurants, and the surf beyond.

• 
  

  Marram

  A love letter to Montauk’s surf culture and laid-back soul, Marram is a barefoot luxury retreat perched directly on the sand. Earthy design elements—whitewashed walls, reclaimed wood, native grasses—evoke the coastal dunes, while the saltwater pool, daily meditation, and roster of wellness programming invite guests to unplug. The on-site restaurant, Mostrador Marram, serves fresh, locally inspired fare, best enjoyed on the deck at sunset. With direct access to the area’s best waves and a focus on conscious hospitality, Marram is Montauk’s ultimate oceanside sanctuary.

• 
  

  The Reform Club

  Set amid English gardens and mature trees, this former boarding house now offers a small collection of suites and private cottages, each individually decorated with bespoke furnishings. Guests are invited to make the estate their own. Lounge in the sun-dappled conservatory, stroll to the nearby Atlantic beaches, or simply relax with a glass of local wine on the sprawling lawns. Discreet service and thoughtful amenities make every visit feel like a return home.

Elite Traveler may earn commission if you book through some of the links above.