After the fire, the Rooks moved into the 842 Holdings property—about 2,000 square feet and intended as a rental—while their destroyed home was nearly 3,200 square feet with higher-end finishes. In a March 21, 2025 letter, they pointed to comparable rentals in Durango at about $4,000 per month and said boarding five horses would average $2,200. They later proposed a monthly ALE figure of $9,280.